2024 Ford Mustang GT vs Nissan Z comparison

Posted on August 16, 2024Comments Off on 2024 Ford Mustang GT vs Nissan Z comparison

It’s been a long time coming for buyers, but the new S550 Ford Mustang has finally arrived on Australian soil.

Based on a familiar recipe, the seventh-generation Mustang GT blends the evergreen ‘Coyote’ V8 with modern technology and revised styling. Think of it as an extensive makeover rather than an all-new model.

Almost two years have passed since the Mustang was unveiled in the US, and deliveries are only just reaching local customers now – which begs a question…

Should suitors have skipped the wait completely and bought into the readily available Nissan Z? And now that the Mustang is available, is it even the better car?

Japan has a long history of producing cracking sports cars, and the Z has plenty of the right ingredients.

It’s lighter than its American rival, and just as quick in most scenarios. Like the Mustang, the Z nameplate also carries plenty of heritage.

If that doesn’t inspire you, just look at the thing! To top it off, the Nissan is cheaper.

Both are offered with a manual gearbox, so this one’s for your motoring purists!

Here we’re focusing on the best-selling Mustang GT and standard Z. Each boast unique selling points, so let’s see how they stack up on the spec sheet.

Pricing

The Ford Mustang occupies both the top and bottom ends of the price band shared by these two rivals, but the most directly comparable variants are the Mustang GT and standard Z.

In both automatic and manual guise the Ford is a more expensive proposition, with self-shifting examples commanding a $5102 premium and the manual variant priced $1202 dearer than the Z.

If you want to step up the track-ready flagships, then the Z Nismo is offered for $94,000 plus on-road costs, while the Mustang Dark Horse starts at $99,102 before on-roads.

Model Variant Price before on-road costs
2024 Ford Mustang EcoBoost Auto $64,990
2024 Nissan Z Auto $75,800
2024 Nissan Z Manual $75,800
2024 Ford Mustang GT Manual $77,002
2024 Ford Mustang GT Auto $80,902
2024 Ford Mustang GT Convertible Auto $86,752
2024 Nissan Z Nismo Auto $94,000
2024 Ford Mustang Dark Horse Manual $99,102
2024 Ford Mustang Dark Horse Auto $103,002

Drivetrains and efficiency

From a powertrain perspective, the Mustang and Z couldn’t be more different.

Like Mustangs of old, the current-generation GT is powered by a big-block naturally aspirated V8, mated to either a close-ratio 10-speed automatic or six-speed manual transmission.

On the other hand, the Z has adopted a 3.0-litre twin-turbocharged V6, straying from the naturally aspirated formula of the preceding 350Z and 370Z.

As some say, there’s no replacement for displacement, and the pony car has the edge in the power stakes. However, the lighter Nissan is quicker in the 0-100km/h sprint, and more fuel efficient. Both cars are rear-wheel drive across the range.

The Mustang EcoBoost offers similar performance for much less money, with the added bonus of four-cylinder efficiency.

Ford Mustang EcoBoost Nissan Z Ford Mustang GT Nissan Z Nismo Ford Mustang Dark Horse
Engine 2.3L 4cyl turbo 3.0L twin-turbo V6 5.0L naturally aspirated V8 3.0L twin-turbo V6 5.0L naturally aspirated V8
Power 232kW 298kW 347kW 309kW 349kW
Torque 475Nm 475Nm 550Nm 520Nm 548Nm
Transmission 10-speed automatic 9-speed automatic or 6-speed manual 10-speed automatic or 6-speed manual 9-speed automatic 10-speed automatic or 6-speed manual
Driven wheels Rear-wheel drive Rear-wheel drive Rear-wheel drive Rear-wheel drive Rear-wheel drive
Power-to-weight ratio 135.8kW/t 187.5kW/t (auto)
191.5kW/t (manual)
192.5kW/t (auto)
195.5kW/t (manual)
189kW/t 193.5kW/t (auto)
195.6kW/t (manual)
0-100km/h 5.3s 4.7s (as tested) 4.9s (auto)
5.3s (manual)
N/A N/A
Fuel economy (claimed) 9.4L/100km 9.8L/100km (auto)
10.8L/100km (manual)
12.8L/100km (auto)
13.6L/100km (manual)
10.4L/100km 12.8L/100km
Fuel tank capacity 61L 62L 61L 62L 61L
Fuel type 98 RON 95 RON 98 RON 95 RON 98 RON
C02 (combined) 215g/km 227g/km (auto)
250g/km (manual)
293g/km (auto)
310g/km (manual)
242g/km 293g/km (auto)
353g/km (manual)

Dimensions

If the differing heritage of these competitors wasn’t obvious before, it should be now.

The American born and bred Mustang is bigger in every dimension, with considerably more heft to haul around. On the bright side, the extra size translates to a bigger boot.

Despite its Japanese roots, the Z is by no means light or petite, but it’s certainly the more compact machine featured here.

Ford Mustang EcoBoost Nissan Z Ford Mustang GT Nissan Z Nismo Ford Mustang Dark Horse
Length 4811mm 4380mm 4811mm 4410mm 4823mm
Width 2097mm 1845mm 2097mm 1870mm 2097mm
Height 1407mm 1315mm 1414mm 1315mm 1413mm
Wheelbase 2719mm 2550mm 2719mm 2550mm 2719mm
Boot capacity 375L 241L 375L 241L 375L
Kerb weight 1746kg 1633kg (auto)
1600kg (manual)
1841kg (auto)
1813kg (manual)
1635kg 1842kg (auto)
1822kg (manual)

Servicing and warranty

Both vehicles here offer a five-year, unlimited-kilometre warranty.

The Z comes with higher running costs though, especially over the first four services. Ford offers $379 capped price servicing over the first four years, which Nissan only matches in the first year of ownership.

Ford Mustang Nissan Z (auto)
Warranty 5 years, unlimited kilometres 5 years, unlimited kilometres
Interval 12 months or 15,000km 12 months or 10,000km
1st service $379 $347
2nd service $379 $500
3rd service $379 $495
4th service $379 $771
5th service $N/A $391
Total first 5 years $1516 (4 years) $2504 (5 years)
Avg. service price $379 (4 years) $500.80 (5 years)

Safety

Neither the new Ford Mustang nor Nissan Z have been tested by ANCAP or Euro NCAP.

Nevertheless, the Mustang offers more standard safety equipment with an extra airbag and the inclusion of lane-keep assist which isn’t available for the Z.

Neither has a surround-view camera or park assist, but that’s unlikely to concern dedicated sports car buyers.

Ford Mustang Nissan Z
Airbags 7 airbags 6 airbags
Autonomous emergency braking (AEB) Yes Yes
Lane-keep assist Yes No
Blind-spot monitoring Yes Yes
Adaptive cruise control Yes Yes
Traffic sign recognition Yes Yes
Reversing camera Yes Yes
Surround-view camera No No
Rear cross-traffic alert Yes Yes
Parking sensors Yes Yes
Park assist No No
Tyre pressure monitoring Yes Yes

Standard features

The Ford Mustang GT and Nissan Z demonstrate different priorities on the spec sheet.

Exterior features Ford Mustang GT Nissan Z
Wheels 19-inch alloy wheels 19-inch alloy wheels
Tyres 255/40 R19 front and 275/40 R19 rear Pirelli P-Zero tyres 255/40R19 front and 275/35 R19 rear Bridgestone Potenza S007 tyres
Spare wheel Tyre repair kit Tyre repair kit
Headlights Automatic LED headlights Automatic LED headlights
Fog lights No Rear fog light
Wipers Rain-sensing wipers Intermittent variable wipers
Side mirrors Power-folding and heated side mirrors Power-folding and heated side mirrors
Sunroof No, convertible option No
Tailgate Manual tailgate Manual tailgate

Externally, there’s plenty of crossover between the pair although the Mustang has the advantage of automatic rain-sensing wipers.

Neither model comes with a sunroof, but a truly open-air experience can be had with the Mustang Convertible.

Interior features Ford Mustang GT Nissan Z
Upholstery Leather-accented upholstery Leather-accented upholstery
Front seats 6-way power-adjustable, heated and cooled front seats 4-way power-adjustable, heated front seats
Rear seats Yes No
Steering wheel Leather-wrapped steering wheel Leather-wrapped steering wheel
Paddle shifters Yes Yes
Rear-view mirror Electrochromatic rear-view mirror Auto-dimming rearview mirror
Climate control Dual-zone climate control Dual-zone climate control

Want a sports car but need space for the whole family? It’ll be a tight fit in the 2+2 seat Mustang, and an impossibility in the strictly two-seat Z.

Both cars have power-adjustable front seats with a heating function, while the Mustang adds seat cooling.

Leather upholstery is another shared feature, which helps to set these cars apart from more affordable sports cars such as the Toyota GR86/Subaru BRZ and Mazda MX-5.

Technology Ford Mustang GT Nissan Z
Instrument cluster 12.4-inch digital instrument cluster 12.3-inch digital instrument cluster
Head-up display No No
Infotainment 13.2-inch touchscreen 8.0-inch touchscreen
Satellite navigation Yes No
Smartphone mirroring Wireless mirroring Wired mirroring
Phone charging Wireless charging Wired charging
USB 1 x USB-A, 1 x USB-C 1 x USB-A, 1 x USB-C
Sound system 12-speaker B&O sound system 8-speaker Bose sound system
Key Keyless entry and start Keyless entry and start

The Mustang is a clear winner in the technology stakes.

You get a whopping 13.2-inch infotainment screen in the Ford, dwarfing the Z’s 8.0-inch unit. Ford’s SYNC software features satellite navigation, which is unavailable in the Z.

You’ll also need a cable for smartphone mirroring and charging in the Nissan, both of which can be done wirelessly in the Mustang.

Four extra speakers top off Ford’s tech offering, a selling point given the Z’s old-school roots.

Would you pay up for American muscle, or opt for the more nimble, boosted Z?

MORE: Buy a Ford Mustang
MORE: Everything Ford Mustang

MORE: Buy a Nissan Z
MORE: Everything Nissan Z